✦ ShadeVault

Best Dupes for Star Balm Magic Mint Lip Balm (2026)

We found 5 verified dupes for Star Balm Star Balm Magic Mint Lip Balm, ranked by shade accuracy, formula overlap, and community consensus.

The OriginalStar Balm

Star Balm Magic Mint Lip Balm

$0
FA Safe
vs
#1 MatchBurt's Bees

Coconut & Pear Moisturizing Lip Balm

$0
FFFA Safe
88%Shade
53%Formula
357Mentions

Shop the original

🛒Shop Amazon💄Shop Sephora✨Shop Ulta

Shop the dupe

🛒Shop Amazon💄Shop Sephora✨Shop Ulta
88%Shade Match
53%Formula Similarity
1,542Community Mentions

All 5 Dupes, Ranked

1
Burt's Bees

Coconut & Pear Moisturizing Lip Balm

88%Shade
53%Formula
357Mentions
$0View Details
FFFA Safe
2
Burt's Bees

Sweet Mandarin Moisturizing Lip Balm

74%Shade
59%Formula
466Mentions
$0View Details
FFFA Safe
3
Dr. Squatch

Moisturizing Lip Balm Vanilla Bourbon

67%Shade
78%Formula
80Mentions
$0View Details
FFFA Safe
4
Burt's Bees

Strawberry Moisturizing Lip Balm

65%Shade
63%Formula
403Mentions
$0View Details
FFFA Safe
5
Nature's Bees

Cocoa butter lip balm

54%Shade
56%Formula
236Mentions
$0View Details
FFFA Safe

Community Verified

These dupes have been discussed across 1,542 Reddit threads and beauty forums. Scores reflect shade match accuracy, ingredient overlap, and real user sentiment.

See Also

L'Oréal

Dupes for Baby Lips Electro Strike a Rose

Le Petit Olivier

Dupes for Baume Lèvres Hydratant Huile d'Olive

Rimmel

Dupes for Baume à lèvres 040 rose blush

Burt's Bees

Dupes for Burt's Bees Overnight Lip Treatment

Nature's Bees

Dupes for Cocoa butter lip balm

Burt's Bees

Dupes for Coconut & Pear Moisturizing Lip Balm